So for this week's assignment we had to learn all about copyright law and then give a critique of an educational video found on TeacherTube, discussing how well or not they adhered to copyright laws and fair use limitations.
We Didn't Start the Fire
This video, it seems, was a bit abusive of the Fair Use guidelines. While it was produced under the presumption that it gives an overview of modern-American history, it actually turned out to be more of a music video set to a Billy Joel song. While I love Billy Joel, no citations were ever given in regards to the song that played the entire video, or any of the images used. They acquired dozens of images and movie clips from important moments in American history that, arguably, would be educationally beneficial to use when teaching the subject. However, under the terms of fair use, the amount of images used was a bit excessive and the video seemed to be more entertainment oriented, rather than educationally oriented. Had they even given recognition to Billy Joel for use of his song, or listed a sort of "works cited" from whence they gathered the images to make the video, then yes, I would argue that it was all done under fair use. However, since no effort was made to cite any of the sources, I would say that this video is indeed under violation of copyright law, even if it was intended for an educational purpose.
A Fair(y) Use Tale
This film was, first and foremost, quite entertaining. It is a video about Fair Use, done humorously, made entirely of short snippits of Disney cartoons. The best part is they actually demonstrated and excellent example of Fair Use to teach the idea of Fair Use to educators. All the films and music that they used were cited properly in the credits at the end. The extent of the clips used was not excessive, and it was CLEARLY educational and for an educational purpose. This may arguably be the BEST example of Fair Use and copyright law in education ever to exist...ever!
IPT286 for Fall 2012!
13 years ago
